Financial Astrology: Can Planetary Cycles Predict Markets?

Illustration of a half-illuminated Moon above financial candlestick charts, combining lunar cycles and market analysis in Finansified's blue palette.

In 2003, some retail forex traders were deciding when to buy and sell currencies with the help of planetary forecasts. We know because we saw it happening. One surviving MetaTrader statement from that period shows a trader making just four trades in a month and roughly doubling the account. Alongside it was an astrological forecast describing supposedly favorable planetary conditions for making money. To a novice trader, the combination could look remarkably convincing.

But a profitable month is not evidence that the planets predicted anything. That is the more interesting question behind financial astrology: can planetary cycles provide information about future market movements that survives proper statistical testing? Some academic studies have, in fact, reported unusual relationships between celestial cycles and financial returns. Others have failed to reproduce them. So rather than dismissing financial astrology because it sounds implausible, we will apply the same standard we should apply to any claimed trading edge: define the rule, test it, and see whether the result survives.

What Is Financial Astrology?

Financial astrology is the practice of using planetary and lunar cycles to anticipate changes in financial markets. Practitioners look for recurring relationships between celestial events and market behavior, particularly changes in timing, volatility, sentiment or trend. The methods vary considerably. Some track lunar phases, eclipses or planetary retrogrades. Others study aspects, the angles formed between planets. Some compare current planetary positions with a chart constructed for a company, stock exchange or the date an asset first began trading.

The underlying claim is stronger than simply saying markets move in cycles. Conventional financial analysis can also study recurring seasonal or economic patterns without involving astrology. Financial astrology specifically proposes that planetary positions or astrological relationships contain information about future market behavior.

That distinction matters. A trader does not need to prove that planets physically move markets to claim a useful forecasting rule. But the rule itself should still produce predictions that can be defined in advance and tested against market data. And traders have been trying to do exactly that for decades.

A Short History of Financial Astrology

Modern financial astrology predates the internet trading era by decades. In 1948, astrologer Donald Bradley developed what became known as the Bradley model, an attempt to combine planetary relationships into a single indicator for stock-market turning points. David Williams later published Astro-Economics in 1955, another early attempt to connect planetary cycles with financial markets.

One of the better-known later practitioners was Arch Crawford, who had worked in technical analysis at Merrill Lynch. Crawford said he first encountered financial astrology in 1963 after reading a newspaper article about astrologers attempting to forecast the stock market. He then studied Bradley’s work and began combining planetary-cycle analysis with conventional technical indicators.

Crawford eventually launched the Crawford Perspectives newsletter in 1977. His reputation grew after a well-publicized call ahead of the 1987 market crash, when he warned that the bull market was approaching a major turning point.

But his record also illustrates a problem we will return to later: memorable successes can coexist with failed forecasts and much less impressive long-term performance. Financial astrology nevertheless survived and eventually followed traders into the rapidly expanding world of online retail trading.

What Financial Astrology Looked Like in Retail Forex

By the early 2000s, financial astrology had found its way into the growing retail forex market. We saw this firsthand. Traders circulated planetary forecasts, astrological charts and market predictions alongside the same technical indicators and trading statements that were becoming common on early online trading platforms. One surviving example from May 2003 is particularly revealing.

The astrological chart accompanying the material described conditions as favorable for making money. In astrological terms, the second house—associated with wealth—contained the Sun and Venus, while Jupiter was positioned favorably relative to them. Alongside that forecast was a MetaTrader 3 statement from a trader who made only four trades during the month. The account roughly doubled.

The trades were opened in the evening and left to reach either their take-profit or stop-loss levels. From the statement, the initial reward-to-risk relationship appears to have been about 2:1. For a new trader, the combination was powerful: an unusual forecasting method, a simple trading routine and an account statement showing spectacular short-term results. But the statement cannot tell us why those trades succeeded.

Four trades are far too few to establish predictive ability. We do not know what would have happened over the next 40, 400 or 4,000 trades, nor whether unsuccessful forecasts circulated as widely as the successful ones.

That is precisely why examples like this are so persuasive—and so dangerous as evidence. A striking result can make a method look validated long before we have enough observations to determine whether it contains any genuine predictive information.

What Would Count as Evidence?

A profitable trade—or even an impressive historical pattern—is not enough to establish that financial astrology works. A useful test must begin with a specific rule defined before looking at the outcome. For example: when a particular planetary configuration occurs, a particular market should behave in a specified way over a specified period.

That matters because financial astrology offers enormous flexibility. Researchers or traders can choose among planets, aspects, lunar phases, eclipses, retrogrades, markets, time horizons and definitions of a “turning point.” Test enough combinations and some can appear successful purely by chance.

This is the problem of multiple testing or data snooping, and it is not unique to astrology. Quantitative trading strategies, technical indicators and conventional financial factors face exactly the same problem.

A convincing result therefore needs to clear several hurdles:

Evidence standard

From a Trading Claim to a Testable Edge

A historical pattern becomes more convincing only as it survives increasingly demanding tests.

  1. Define the rule
  2. Test it statistically
  3. Adjust for multiple testing
  4. Test it on unseen data
  5. Replicate it independently
  6. Account for trading costs

The standard rises at each stage: a visually interesting pattern is not the same thing as a robust, economically usable edge.

FINANSIFIED · finansified.com

Each step asks a different question. Is the pattern distinguishable from chance? Does it survive outside the data used to discover it? Can someone else reproduce it? And, finally, is any remaining effect large enough to trade after spreads, slippage and other costs? That is the standard we should use when examining the research—not whether the underlying idea sounds conventional or strange.

What Does the Research Actually Find?

Research into celestial cycles and financial markets has produced some intriguing results but not a stable body of evidence for financial astrology. One of the better-known findings concerns the lunar cycle. Ilia Dichev and Troy Janes reported that stock returns during the 15 days around new moons were roughly twice those during the 15 days around full moons. They found the pattern across major US indices and many international markets.

Lunar cycle explorer

Explore the Moon's Phase

Select a date to see the Moon's phase, illuminated fraction and position in the lunar cycle. The astronomy is measurable; whether it predicts financial returns is a separate empirical question.

Calculating…

Calculating…

—

Lunar conditions

Illuminated — Visible portion of the lunar disk
Direction — Growing or shrinking illumination
Cycle position — New Moon = 0%, Full Moon = 50%
Approx. lunar age — Days since the previous New Moon

Previous primary phase

—

—

Next primary phase

—

—

Research view

Where This Date Falls in the Lunar Cycle

Financial-market studies have compared returns around different parts of the lunar cycle, particularly New and Full Moons. The exact event windows and statistical specifications vary by study.

Astronomical observation ≠ trading signal. The Moon's phase can be measured precisely. Whether returns differ systematically around those phases—and whether any difference survives out-of-sample testing and trading costs—is a separate question.

Method: Lunar phase and illumination are calculated locally in the browser. Adjacent primary-phase times are numerical estimates and are displayed in UTC.
FINANSIFIED · finansified.com

A larger study by Kathy Yuan, Lu Zheng and Qiaoqiao Zhu later examined stock indices from 48 countries. It also found lower average returns around full moons than around new moons, with an estimated annualized difference of roughly 3% to 5% in its global portfolios. The authors tested several alternative explanations but also acknowledged an important possibility: when researchers search historical returns for patterns, some statistically significant relationships will arise by chance.

Subsequent evidence became less clear. Stephen Keef and Mohammed Khaled re-examined 62 international stock indices using a different model. They found evidence of higher returns around new moons, but no corresponding evidence that returns around full moons were unusually low. In other words, changing the specification changed the interpretation of the anomaly.

Then, in 2013, Erhard Reschenhofer and Michaela Lingler approached the question with a different statistical method designed to detect common cycles across financial time series. They found no significant relationship between lunar phases and stock returns and argued that contradictory earlier findings could be traced to data-snooping effects.

A separate line of research has examined geomagnetic activity rather than astrology. A Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta working paper reported lower subsequent stock returns following unusually intense geomagnetic activity and proposed investor mood as a possible transmission mechanism.

That finding is interesting, but it is important not to confuse categories. A measurable environmental variable associated with market behavior is not evidence that astrological interpretations of planets can forecast prices. The research therefore gives us something more useful than a simple yes-or-no answer: it shows how an apparently persistent market anomaly can weaken as researchers change specifications and apply more demanding tests.

Correlation Is Not Astrology

Even if a celestial cycle were reliably associated with market returns, that would not automatically validate financial astrology. Suppose future research consistently found that stock returns differed around certain lunar phases. That would establish a statistical relationship worth investigating. It would not demonstrate that the Moon carries the astrological meanings assigned to it, or that planetary aspects, zodiac signs or market birth charts can forecast prices.

The same distinction applies to geomagnetic activity. Researchers have proposed a testable chain in which solar activity affects geomagnetic conditions, which may influence human mood and, in turn, financial decisions. Whether that mechanism ultimately survives further research is an empirical question—but it does not require an astrological explanation.

This distinction matters because an anomaly and an explanation for that anomaly are separate claims. First we must establish that a pattern is real and robust. Only then can we ask what mechanism might produce it.

Financial astrology makes an additional claim: that astrological relationships themselves contain useful information about future market behavior. That proposition requires evidence of its own.

Why Financial Astrology Can Look Convincing

Financial astrology does not need to predict markets consistently to feel persuasive. Markets generate enormous amounts of noisy data, and dramatic turning points are especially memorable. If a planetary forecast appears shortly before a crash or rally, that success is easy to notice and retell. Forecasts that miss may receive far less attention.

Several familiar cognitive biases reinforce this effect. Confirmation bias encourages us to notice evidence that supports an existing belief. Hindsight bias makes a past market move appear more predictable after it has happened. Availability bias gives memorable successes greater weight than uneventful failures.

Then there is the statistical problem. If traders can examine many planets, aspects, dates, markets and time horizons, they can generate a huge number of possible relationships. Searching long enough through historical data makes it increasingly likely that some patterns will look impressive by chance.

A further problem is survivorship. We usually encounter the forecasts, traders or systems that became interesting enough to preserve. Failed predictions and abandoned methods are less likely to survive in newsletters, screenshots or trading forums.

None of these problems is unique to astrology. The same mechanisms can make technical indicators, quantitative strategies and backtests appear more convincing than they really are. That is why isolated successes matter much less than a rule that continues to work under predefined, out-of-sample testing.

Does Financial Astrology Provide a Trading Edge?

Based on the evidence reviewed here, there is no robust basis for concluding that financial astrology provides a repeatable trading edge. Some studies have reported relationships between lunar cycles and market returns. But those findings have not remained stable across different samples and statistical methods. Later research has weakened or eliminated some of the apparent effects and, in at least one case, traced conflicting results to data snooping.

More importantly, evidence of a celestial-market anomaly would still fall short of validating an astrological trading system. The relevant question is whether any apparent predictability produces persistent abnormal returns. A usable strategy would need predefined rules that continue to predict returns on data that were not used to discover them, survive independent replication, and remain economically meaningful after trading costs.

That is a demanding standard but it should be. The same burden of proof applies to technical indicators, quantitative factors, AI-generated signals or any other method claiming to forecast markets. An unusual idea should not be rejected merely because it is unusual. But neither should an attractive chart, a famous forecast or a profitable month be mistaken for evidence of predictive ability.

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about what financial astrology claims and how those claims can be evaluated.

What is financial astrology?

Financial astrology is the use of planetary positions, lunar phases, astrological aspects and related celestial cycles to anticipate changes in financial markets. Practitioners may use these signals to identify possible turning points, volatility changes or shifts in market sentiment.

Does financial astrology work?

There is currently no robust evidence that financial astrology provides a repeatable trading edge. Some studies have reported relationships between lunar cycles and market returns, but those findings have not remained consistent across different datasets and statistical methods. A reliable trading strategy would also need to survive out-of-sample testing, independent replication and trading costs.

Have researchers found links between lunar phases and stock returns?

Yes. Several studies have reported differences in average stock returns around new and full moons. However, later research produced weaker or null results, and one re-analysis attributed conflicting findings partly to data-snooping effects. A lunar-return anomaly would also not, by itself, validate astrological interpretations of planetary movements.

Can financial astrology be tested scientifically?

Yes—provided the forecasting rule is defined precisely enough to produce a falsifiable prediction. A researcher could specify the planetary condition, market, expected direction and time horizon in advance, then test the rule on data that were not used to develop it.

Is financial astrology the same as studying market cycles?

No. Financial markets can exhibit seasonal, economic and behavioral cycles without astrology. Financial astrology makes the additional claim that planetary positions or astrological relationships contain useful information about future market behavior. That claim requires evidence of its own.

Conclusion

Financial astrology has produced memorable forecasts, unusual market anecdotes and a small body of research reporting relationships between celestial cycles and financial returns. What it has not produced is robust evidence of a repeatable trading edge. That distinction matters. Interesting correlations can justify further investigation, but they do not establish an astrological mechanism and they are especially vulnerable when researchers can search many variables, markets and time periods until something appears significant.

The appropriate standard is therefore the same one we should apply to any forecasting method: define the rule in advance, test it on unseen data, replicate the result and determine whether any predictive value survives trading costs.

So far, financial astrology has not cleared that bar.

Disclaimer

This article is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute financial, investment or trading advice. Historical market relationships, statistical anomalies and research findings do not guarantee future performance. Any trading strategy should be independently evaluated, including its risks, assumptions and transaction costs.

References
  1. Dichev, I. D., & Janes, T. D. (2003). “Lunar Cycle Effects in Stock Returns.” The Journal of Private Equity, 6(4), 8–29. DOI: 10.3905/jpe.2003.320053.

  2. Yuan, K., Zheng, L., & Zhu, Q. (2006). “Are Investors Moonstruck? Lunar Phases and Stock Returns.” Journal of Empirical Finance, 13(1), 1–23. DOI: 10.1016/j.jempfin.2005.06.001.

  3. Keef, S. P., & Khaled, M. S. (2011). “Are Investors Moonstruck? Further International Evidence on Lunar Phases and Stock Returns.” Journal of Empirical Finance, 18(1), 56–63. DOI: 10.1016/j.jempfin.2010.11.002.

  4. Reschenhofer, E., & Lingler, M. (2013). “Detecting Synchronous Cycles in Financial Time Series of Unequal Length.” Journal of Empirical Finance, 24, 1–9. DOI: 10.1016/j.jempfin.2013.07.003.

  5. Krivelyova, A., & Robotti, C. (2003). “Playing the Field: Geomagnetic Storms and the Stock Market.” Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta Working Paper No. 2003-5b.

  6. Harvey, C. R., Liu, Y., & Zhu, H. (2016). “…and the Cross-Section of Expected Returns.” The Review of Financial Studies, 29(1), 5–68. DOI: 10.1093/rfs/hhv059.

  7. Bailey, D. H., & López de Prado, M. (2014). “The Deflated Sharpe Ratio: Correcting for Selection Bias, Backtest Overfitting, and Non-Normality.” The Journal of Portfolio Management, 40(5), 94–107. DOI: 10.3905/jpm.2014.40.5.094.

Ready to analyze the macro behind your pairs like institutions do?

Explore how inflation, growth, policy rates, liquidity, confidence, and Taylor Rule benchmarks shape economies behind FX pairs and influence their behaviour. The BETA is live now.